Views on Life & on Equity Investing

Wonder, Wealth & Abundance

Hits and Misses of Past Six Years

with 7 comments

I have bought roughly fifty equities in India and ten overseas over the past six years.

Other than overseas equities in which I am still building position here are list of major hits and misses. 

Misses

1) Zylog: I had researched that company had REAL business, REAL employees, REAL deal but overlooked the management and books.

Company was sold in pieces..

http://www.vccircle.com/news/technology/2014/09/18/ikya-buy-zylogs-canadian-it-engineering-staffing-services-unit

Lost 3% of Capital at 10%allocation.

2) Simran Farms: Bought at 20 Rs at MCAP / Sales ratio of 0.1.

Was not a loser but made only 30% after holding for over 1.5 years.

3) VIKAS WSP: Bought at 70 INR, sold at 40 INR, lost 4% of capital at 10% allocation. Fracking industry returned several multibaggers in the United states in 2012, 2013 but B.D.Aggarwal’s heart throbs for farmers and not investors. Happy to pay 100 Crore donation cheque for hospital but not a 13 Crore dividend cheque to shareholders.

4) OMNITEX and PHOTOQUIP: Did not lose capital but opportunity cost by holding them.


5) CRAVATEX: FILA isn’t as premium a brand and profitable. Trading margins thin. Did not lose capital but opportunity cost by holding them. Infact made 70% but did not sell at highs of 800 but at 300-400 post correction. POLAR was a monopoly in heart rate monitors but business size is quite small. Companies like Jawbone are likely to give a tough time to POLAR.

Similarly, Johnson Health Tech is third biggest company that is one of the principals of Cravatex but competition in health equipment is intense in India.

Global #1 Golf brand Titleist acquisition materialized for FILA Global but did not traslate to business for Cravatex.

Despite the mistakes, portfolio construction saved the day. 

A long series of two-three baggers and an occasional 10-20-30 bagger returned ~46x of the original equity portfolio since 2008. 90% Cagr from 2007-2011, 50% Cagr from 2011 – 2013, 300% CAGR in 2014. 1 Lac INR turned to 46 Lac INR ( 1* 1.9* 1.9* 1.9* 1.5* 1.5 * 3 )

Some of the help in compounding came from:

ASTRAL POLYTECHNIK
RELAXO
SYMPHONY
HAWKINS COOKERS
TTK PRESTIGE
PAGE INDUSTRIES
ATUL AUTO
RS SOFTWARE
GULSHAN POLYOLS
SUPERHOUSE
MUTHOOT CAPITAL
WIM PLAST
ACRYSIL
CERA SANITARYWARE
AMRUTANJAN
BAJAJ FINANCE
CANFIN HOMES
MONEY MATTERS (renamed to CAPRI  GLOBAL)
MANAPPURAM
KOVAI MEDICAL
KITEX
MAYUR UNIQUOTERS
THANGAMAYIL 
BAJAJ CORP
NILKAMAL 
PODDAR DEVELOPERS
VINYL CHEMICALS

Sorry if you only bought the losers amongst my recommendations and not the winners.

About 20 stocks are not mentioned above which did not become either big time winners or losers such as Josts Engineering, Empire Industries (except in 2014), ICRA.

One word of caution: If you cannot digest 10% losers in portfolio, invest only in Nestle, Unilever, HDFC and the ilk.

In equities large caps make money, small caps makes moolah, trading, speculating holding for two months makes money, sometime holding patiently for a decade is futile. In the absence of a prosaic formula it will continue to be an adventurous game of trial and error. Find what suits your temperament.

For example people cite investing for long term makes real wealth, that did not fructify for HUL and GSK investors who did not see a return of dime for 10 years in India. Another example people cite from Jesse Livermore is “it was my sitting patiently that made money”. In my past seven years I made less money by sitting patiently but made more money on Poddar Developers by allocating huge weight 250 INR IN 750 INR OUT. I made biggest money on that trade of 3 months.

For the partnership fund however, biggest money and biggest weight eventually came by Buy-and-Hold for couple of years on Atul Auto, Wim Plast, Cera and Bajaj Finance. Buy and Hold gains did kick in on Kovai Medical recently. Proving that both trading and investing works.

However, I have toned down my expectations and quite content with 15-17% returns with less portfolio churn, primarily in market leaders or near-monopolies of other emerging countries.

Average holding period in portfolio was 2.5 years. I expect that to increase to ~5 years now with lower returns.

If you are looking for an ace investor cum trader in India, follow Safir’s blog. 

Anti-fragile


My maternal and paternal grandparents lost all material wealth in partition of India like millions of others. I wasn’t there to see their pain but indirectly did.


In fact, refugee class is still rife in Africa. Even amongst American millionaires, banks provide the same experience.


Banks frequently go under taking all life savings of investors in Hedge Funds, many fund manager share their nightmare including Guy Spier in his book “Education of a Value Investor”, all funds were locked up in Bear Sterns.


A person I know in India recently lost most of the money for his commodity firm in National Spot Exchange Limited.


India has not yet seen the kind of bank failures as prevalent and common in the West, nor mass refugee class.

  
I have myself lost 100% of my investment in a UK Bank, Northern Rock in 2008 roughly ~20,000 Dollars.

https://www.fdic.gov/bank/individual/failed/banklist.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bank_failures_in_the_United_States_%282008%E2%80%93present%29#List_of_bank_failures_in_2014

Always remember the game of stock market is not to make money slowest, surest, fastest BUT a game to be enjoyed in bull times, and to be sucked up to in bear phases. The real game is to have the staying power, to survive, to be hardy, and to forever have the wherewithal and funds to invest.

Ergo, to be Anti-fragile, you MUST invest your money in five different banks, five different brokers, and also if possible 3+ countries. If 25 equities fulfill our 15% hurdle rate, why not spread them in 4 countries ?

A few mistakes are inevitable, otherwise you are playing too safe. Don’t be afraid of few failures on the way, a necessity for growth!

Be resiliently anti-fragilely rich!

Disclosure: Invested in stocks discussed. Views are personal notions and do not represent any organisation or company. I am not an investment adviser. Investment in stock market can (and many a times do) result in loss of principal capital.

Written by amitdipsite

January 8, 2015 at 7:34 pm

Posted in Uncategorized

7 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Investing quote from myself on Material Wealth Creation (It = Wealth): “Society nurtures humanity, culture provide a pillar to it, stakeholders create it, companies only report it, employees have to slog for it but Investors milk and cream it”.

    Amit Arora

    January 9, 2015 at 9:54 pm

  2. Sir any recommendations for 2015 from Indian stock market. Pls sir not for Me but for all ur followers and readers one company at least for 2015. Thanks in advance.

    Nirav Karia

    January 10, 2015 at 5:11 am

  3. good learning

    HARSHIT JAIN

    January 10, 2015 at 10:42 am

  4. Mr Amit somebody has already asked your view on Associated alcohols and brewery ltd in Africa revisted thread even I found it very interesting on reported numbers can you throw some light please. Thank you

    kumaresh ramachandran

    January 11, 2015 at 12:07 pm

  5. Respected Sir ,
    EXCELLENT . Because of your Honesty , streaming from your blog . Each word u read and I have more Respect for you .
    Thank for such articles and warm Regards.
    Vakharia Mahesh

    Mahesh Spiritual

    January 20, 2015 at 4:55 am

  6. Truly Amazing!

    Is the CAGR only of Indian stocks or overseas included?

    PV

    February 5, 2015 at 11:43 am

  7. I started equity market investing in 1999 when I lost 70% of my principal capital. Then stopped for 8 years.

    In 2007 I started again and lost all my principal capital in 2008. This is only India.

    Serious about overseas investing only since 2012.

    Amit Arora

    February 6, 2015 at 1:30 am


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: